On July 17, 1918, the last Czar of Russia Nicholas II, his
wife Alexandra, and their five children were brutally murdered
by revolutionaries known as the Bolsheviks. Though the Bolsheviks claimed to
have murdered the entire family, their bodies were mutilated and subsequently
buried in unmarked graves which led to speculation that the youngest daughter
of the five Romanov children, Anastasia, had escaped.
The rumors seemed all but confirmed when just a few years
later a mysterious woman appeared in Berlin and was admitted to a psychiatric
facility. The legend of the escaped Grand Duchess and the notion that the
mysterious woman could be none other than Anastasia swirled across Europe and continued
well into the 1980s. But were the rumors true?
The Bolsheviks, whose revolution would eventually create the
ruling communist party in Russia, sent the Romanov family to live in exile in a
small house in the city of Yekaterinburg. For 78 days the family was held in five
small rooms under constant surveillance as their captors grew increasingly
paranoid about a possible rescue attempt.
On the morning of July 17th, the family was ushered into the
basement where a bloodbath ensued. Overall, the executions had taken 20
minutes. The bodies were then stripped, burned by fire or in acid, and buried
in an abandoned mineshaft. The family’s burial site remained hidden for 61
years following their execution. During this time, the anonymity of their
burials and the knowledge that the children had jewels hidden in their
clothing, led some to believe that a child could have escaped. Rumors spread
and several impostors attempted to claim the royal fortune.
Perhaps the most famous impostor of Anastasia Romanov was an
unstable young woman named Anna Anderson. In 1920, Anna attempted suicide by
jumping off a bridge in Berlin. She survived and was brought to an asylum
without any paperwork or identification.
For six months she refused to identify herself and didn’t
speak a word to the hospital staff. When she eventually did speak, it was determined
that she had a Russian accent. Combined with the distinct scars on her body and
her withdrawn demeanor, this inspired theories among the hospital staff and the
patients.
At least four other women would come forward all claiming to
be the missing Grand Duchess Anastasia Romanov. These women appeared in
different corners of the world at varying times: one appeared in Russia in
1920, another in Chicago in 1963. But none were more famous or had a more
believable case, than Anna Anderson.
When Anderson eventually left the hospital in Berlin, she
was accosted by the press in an attempt to confirm whether or not she was the
Grand Duchess. Since the fall of the Romanov dynasty, Russian aristocrats who
were able to escape the Bolshevik takeover had spread all across Europe along
with the rumors of Anastasia’s resurrection. Anderson was able to find housing
with various aristocrats who had been friends to the Romanov family despite the
fact that Anastasia’s former nursemaid, tutor, and many other former servants
denied that she was the Grand Duchess.
In 1970, a judge ruled in court that there was not
sufficient evidence to prove that Anderson was the Grand Duchess Anastasia.
Anderson was eventually identified as Franziska Schanzkowska, a Polish factory
worker who had gone missing shortly before Anderson turned up in Berlin. She
died in 1984.
The burial site of the Romanovs was discovered in 1979, but
this information wasn’t made public until 1991 because two bodies were still
missing. One of the missing bodies was Alexei and the other was Maria, one of
the Czar’s four daughters. But because the corpses were so damaged, the notion
that the missing daughter could be Anastasia persisted.
That was until 2007 with the discovery of two more remains
near the site. Their DNA showed that they were the bodies of Alexei and Maria
with Anastasia having been identified among the bodies from the previous
burial.
I came across a news article…actually, it was a couple of
years ago…about the Russian government's desire to reunite the remains of their
last imperial family in one place—the czar, czarina, and their five children.
However, the mission was not without roadblocks, namely the need to satisfy
skeptics about the validity of all the remains.
On September 23, 2015, Russian investigators exhumed the
body of Czar Nicholas Romanov II and his wife, Alexandra, as part of an
investigation into the family's death a hundred years ago—in 1918. It's part of
the ongoing attempt to confirm that the remains really belong to Nicholas,
Alexandra, and their children. Some of the family's remains were tested in the
early 1990s (the early days of DNA testing) with the results being that the
scientists were pretty confident that it was really them. The remains exhumed at
that time included the czar, his wife, three of their children, and several
servants. Two of the children, Alexei and Maria, were unaccounted for at that
time. But the officials weren't able to convince the Russian Orthodox Church
about the authenticity of the remains.
The church officials have not come out with their exact
reasons for doubt. There had been some discussion about the Romanov family
having been canonized in 2000 which made the remains holy relics which required
a different way of treating them. In general, church leaders say they just
aren't convinced. The church's approval is important for bringing the family's
remains together.
The church did, somewhat reluctantly, allow the family's
remains to be interred in the Peter and Paul Cathedral in St. Petersburg where
most of Russia's other czars are buried. But the church still had not accepted
the family's identities in spite of the fact that several rounds of DNA testing
had occurred.
When the remains of Alexei and Maria were subsequently
located (their identities confirmed by DNA testing), those remains were left
sitting on a shelf because the Russian Orthodox Church balked at the idea of
adding them to the family tomb. The church says it believes the family's
remains were destroyed and won't change their position until they are 100
percent sure in spite of the DNA confirmation.
In February 2016 the church once again blocked the reuniting
of the remains. Currently, the most prevalent explanation is that the church
hierarchy wants to avoid the decision because either choice would alienate key
factions. Rejecting the bones will anger some Orthodox adherents, particularly
those outside Russia, while accepting them will incense a conservative domestic
faction that believes the Soviet government somehow faked the original burial
at the time and those aren't the real remains of Czar Nicholas II and his
family.
And the entire effort remains in limbo.